First Coffee Join Free

Catholic in Boston

Catholic
First Coffee

Your matchmaker

We find the
right person for you

No profile browsing. No swiping. Our team reviews your preferences and finds someone genuinely compatible from the Catholic community in Boston.

Get started
92% match
87% match

No more texting purgatory

Straight to
a real date

Every match is a date. We pick the cafe in Boston, set the time, and all you have to do is show up.

Get started
SAT
15
Blue Bottle Coffee
2:00 PM

Privacy first

Your face
stays yours

Upload a selfie, get a beautifully illustrated avatar in 20 seconds. Your real photo is never stored.

Get started
Before
Photo
After
Avatar
Before
Photo
After
Avatar

Simple pricing

Pay per date.
No subscription.

First Coffee

$ 39

per date

  • Curated match from your community
  • Café selected for you
  • Full refund if canceled
Get started

Where we meet

Your coffee spots in Boston

We've handpicked these cafés for their ambiance, space, and quiet enough-for-conversation vibe.

Pavement Coffeehouse

Pavement Coffeehouse

286 Newbury St

Back Bay

"Boston staple since 2009 with a prime Newbury Street location. Spacious seating and great bagels for a relaxed date."

Tatte Bakery & Cafe

Tatte Bakery & Cafe

70 Charles St

Beacon Hill

"Israeli-born bakery-cafe with stunning pastries and warm interiors. Beacon Hill charm makes it a perfect date spot."

Thinking Cup

Thinking Cup

165 Tremont St

Downtown Crossing

"Cozy cafe steps from Boston Common serving Stumptown coffee. Intimate setting with window seats overlooking the park."

This Saturday
could be different.

One person. One café. One real conversation.

Get Started